Fishing Vessel Lacks Proper Lookout in Collision with Bulk Carrier Accolade II (How far away is death?)

A collision between a bulk carrier, Accolade II, and a fishing vessel, Sandgroper, off Port Adelaide highlights the importance of navigation watchkeepers on vessels utilizing all available means to maintain a proper lookout, an ATSB (Australian Transport Safety Bureau) investigation stresses.

Just after 4:30 on the morning of February 29, 2020, the fishing vessel Sandgroper collided with the 108-meter self-discharging bulk carrier Accolade II, just off the entrance to Port Adelaide, in darkness and clear visibility conditions.

Sandgroper sustained significant structural damage to its starboard bow, while Accolade II sustained only minor damage to its deck structures and railings on the ship’s starboard side. In addition, Sandgroper’s anchor was found lodged in Accolade II’s deck railings.

There were no reported injuries on either vessel.

“In the time leading up to the collision, a proper lookout using all available means was not being maintained on board either vessel,” ATSB Director Transport Safety Stuart Macleod said.

“Consequently, neither was aware of the risk of the collision posed by the other, until shortly before the collision, when it was too late to take effective avoiding action.”

Mr. Macleod noted the navigation bridge team onboard Accolade II did not have a complete appreciation of the traffic situation, and of the risk of collision outside the port channel, before they exited the channel prior to the collision.

“In particular, effective use was not made of the ship’s radar and a dedicated lookout was not posted in darkness,” he said.

“And while Sandgroper’s skipper did initially sight Accolade II while it was still in the channel, a proper lookout was not subsequently maintained using all available means, including radar and monitoring the port’s working channel on the radio.”

As a result, Sandgroper’s skipper was not aware that Accolade II had exited the channel, and that a close quarters situation was developing.

“Collisions between trading ships and small vessels continue to occur around the Australian coast, and the safety of fishers and people in small boats continues to be of real concern to the ATSB,” Mr. Macleod said.

“ATSB investigations have consistently shown that keeping a proper lookout by all available means – including radar, radio, and automatic identification system (AIS) transceiver – in accordance with the collision regulations, could have prevented most of these collisions.”

While Sandgroper was not required to be fitted with an AIS transceiver, it would have improved the vessel’s detectability.

“An AIS would have increased the chances of the fishing vessel being detected by Accolade II’s bridge team in sufficient time to avoid collision.”

Sandgroper has subsequently been fitted with an AIS, while the managers of Accolade II have advised the ATSB that a navigational audit of the ship’s operations has since been conducted, resulting in several recommendations to improve the ship’s bridge resource management practices.

Key points

• Fishing vessel and bulk carrier collided in darkness near the entrance to Port Adelaide Harbour;
• A proper lookout using all available means was not being maintained on board either vessel;
• Collisions between trading ships and small vessels on the Australian coast continue to be of concern to the ATSB.

Source, ATSB, “Fishing vessel and bulk carrier collision highlights the importance of a proper lookout,”

Image source/credit, ATSB, “Fishing vessel and bulk carrier collision highlights the importance of a proper lookout,”

Read the ATSB report: MO-2020-001: Collision between Accolade II and Sandgroper Off Port Adelaide, South Australia, on 29 February 2020.

Become trained in troubleshooting and identifying root causes of issues and incidents. 

REGISTER TODAY for a TapRooT® course and gain advantage, experience, and expertise from our professional instructors. Here are listings for our upcoming 2-Day and 5-Day courses:

2-DAY TAPROOT® ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS TRAINING

5-DAY TAPROOT® ADVANCED ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS TEAM LEADER TRAINING

We are global to meet your needs. If you need other times or locations, please see our full selection of COURSES.

If you would like for us to teach a course at your workplace, please REACH OUT HERE to discuss what we can do for you, or call us at 865.539.2139.