Using TapRooT To Improve the Quality of Root Cause Analysis at Nuclear Power Plants
Challenge
The quality of root cause analysis at our five nuclear power plants was criticized by reviewers such as the Nuclear Safety Review Boards, Nuclear Oversight (Quality Assurance), and corporate executives. Our critics noted repeat failures, and stated that the investigations often missed the mark and had weak corrective actions. We needed to find a system that would produce consistent quality root cause analysis.
Action
An improvement plan was developed and implemented. Elements of the improvement plan included process improvements to increase line manager involvement, use of an Events and Causal Factor chart, use of an investigation charter, use of a root cause report checklist, and implementation of the TapRooT® RCA System.
We obtained a TapRooT License Agreement for the five Commonwealth Edison nuclear plant sites, plus the corporate office. Since we were in the midst of a merger, and some of our merger-partner sites were also TapRooT® RCA customers, the final License Agreement includes all 10 nuclear plant sites plus the corporate office. We also sent a core group of investigators to a 5-day advanced class.
We replaced our in-house 5-day root cause analysis class with the 2-Day TapRooT® class and installed SnapCharT® Diagram and Root Cause Tree® software programs on the Local Area Network at each site. We also conducted orientation sessions for plant senior managers.
By the end of April 2001, we had conducted at least one 2-Day TapRooT® Course at each plant site.
Results
The initial reaction to the TapRooT® RCA system by investigators, line managers, and reviewers has been positive. Investigators like the structured approach. Line managers like the consistent results. Reviewers like the consistent quality. Investigators and line managers also like the savings of time for the 2-day class rather than a 5-day class. The investigators also like the SnapCharT® software.
Our reviewers use a 10-question checklist to grade our root cause analysis reports. Prior to the introduction of the TapRooT® System in September 2000, the average report score was about 50%. Since the introduction of the TapRooT® System, the average report score has risen to about 75%. We anticipate continued improvement as we train additional investigators.
The improvement in the report ratings and the investigators’ and managers’ opinions about our new system (TapRooT) might not seem like a major improvement, but we have been working for years to improve our root cause analysis and have tried several other systems. Getting this consistent and significant improvement this far along in our quest for better root cause analysis clearly demonstrates to us the value of the TapRooT® System.
One more piece of evidence that shows how much we value the progress that we have made. Our energy delivery districts (transmission and distribution) needed improved root cause analysis to analyze human performance problems that result in outages for our customers. They have been looking for a way to effectively and consistently evaluate their incidents. The corporate nuclear staff presented the TapRooT® System to the corporate energy delivery staff, and they decided that the system would help them effectively improve performance. They are obtaining a license to implement TapRooT® RCA and install the software for the 10 mid-West energy delivery districts to provide our customers with increased power reliability while Exelon realizes cost savings.
